403(b) Plan Sponsors

Subject to ERISA

Annual Checklist

For 403(b) plan sponsors subject to ERISA, the IRS recommends that plan sponsors annually review all retirement plans for compliance purposes. Review the following key items to assist with proper plan administration.

Governance
Operational Compliance
Employee Education
Information to Review
Status and Eligibility

Review eligibility for church plan and status as a church or QCCO.

Has your organization changed ties with a church, association or denomination? If so, you may no longer be eligible for a church plan. If you think this applies to you or your status has changed, contact GuideStone at 1-888-984- GUIDE (1-888-984-8433), Monday through Friday between the hours of 7 a.m. and 6 p.m. CT.

Written Procedures

Confirm you have written procedures to help your plan administrative personnel administer the plan correctly.

Have you compared your administrative procedures against the Adoption Agreement to ensure they coordinate? If not, do you need to amend your plan or make plan corrections?

Eligibility and Plan Entry

Confirm use of plan's definition of "compensation" and confirm eligibility for contributions.

  • Have you recently read the definition of “compensation” in your Adoption Agreement?
  • Are you including or excluding any part of an employee’s wages that is not in line with the definition of “compensation”?
  • Are you limiting compensation, as defined by the plan, to $350,000 (for 2025, indexed) for the purpose of calculating all contributions? See the IRS.gov for annual changes.
  • Are all employees in the plan eligible? Are any employees active in the plan who are not eligible?
  • Are participants enrolled for employer contributions as of the plan entry date?

Did you know administering compensation incorrectly is the #1 problem found in IRS audits?

Did you know eligibility and plan entry are the #2 and #3 problems found in IRS audits?

Effective Opportunity

Confirm effective opportunity.

  • Are all employees eligible to make their own contributions to the plan receiving an annual notice reminding them of their right to contribute?
  • Do you maintain records of when the notices were provided, who received the notices and the method used to deliver the notices?
  • See the Sample Annual Effective Opportunity Notice.
Contributions

Confirm employees’ contributions and ensure your employees stay within IRS Contribution Limits.

  • Are you remitting employees’ contributions as soon as assets are segregated from your general assets?
  • Do you recalculate contribution amounts when an employee’s compensation changes?
  • Do you run the “Contribution History by Payroll End Date” in the GuideStone Employer Access® Program (EAP) to reconcile contributions actually credited to participant accounts with your payroll records?
  • Have you reviewed the Annual Checklist for Plans with Automatic Enrollment to monitor compliance?
  • Are you familiar with the current contribution limits for 403(b) retirement plans, including the standard deferral limit, age 50 catch-up amount and the age 60-63 catch-up amount? For more details, visit GuideStone.org/ContributionLimits.
  • Have you reviewed the new regulation that requires all catch-up contributions to be made as a Roth contribution for Highly Paid Individuals (HPIs)? For more details, visit GuideStone.org/SecureAct2.
Vesting Schedules

Ensure timely use of forfeitures in plans with vesting schedules.

If your retirement plans include a vesting schedule, have you ensured the plan has used the forfeiture balances in a timely manner? The plan mandates that forfeiture balances remaining at the end of the plan year must be utilized during the following plan year.

Complete Nondiscrimination Testing (NDT) Annually
  • At the beginning of each plan year, do you identify all highly compensated employees (HCEs) for the new plan year?
  • Does plan compensation exclude minister's housing allowance for HCEs? Adjust payroll as needed.
  • Does your plan exclude HCEs from employer contributions or after-tax contributions?
  • Does your testing data include all employees who are not excludable for statutory reasons?
  • Do you provide the data to your tester quickly enough to avoid an excise tax if thetesting fails?
  • Do you maintain documentation of the testing results in case of an audit?
ERISA Compliance

Comply with Department of Labor (DOL) reporting (See DOL Website for more ERISA plan compliance)

  • Is your fidelity bond sufficient based on plan assets as of the end of the prior plan year?
  • Have you filed Form 5500 with the DOL each plan year and maintained copies of all related records?
  • Have you reviewed the annual audit requirements to determine if your plan must have a full audit?
  • Do you provide notices to new hires within 30 days of their hire date (e.g., Effective Opportunity Notice, Summary Plan Description with Summary of Material Modifications, Participant fee disclosure with addendums)?
  • Do you provide annual participant notices once every 14 months?
  • Do you provide the Summary Annual Report to participants by the DOL deadline?
  • Does your plan prohibit employees who normally work less than 20 hours per week from making elective deferrals?
  • If yes, are you tracking their hours worked in 2025 and 2026 to determine if they must be allowed to make deferrals beginning in January 2027? (The SECURE 2.0 Act requires plans that exclude part-time employees to allow them to make elective deferrals if the employee works at least 500 hours in two consecutive plan years).

 

New Employee Orientation

Review new employee orientation process.

  • Do you emphasize plan participation during onboarding to encourage greater savings for your employees?
  • Do you provide new employees with a Plan Summary and appropriate forms in their first-day packet? These are available in EAP.
  • If your plan is a safe harbor plan or has automatic enrollment, do you provide the required notices with the retirement material to new employees?
  • Do you follow up with new employees who do not enroll to encourage retirement savings?
Education Strategy

Develop an education strategy for employees to increase savings with these tips.

  • Provide required applicable annual notices, such as safe harbor or automatic enrollment notices.
  • Emphasize retirement savings to increase overall participation.
  • Review member educational material and inform members of appropriate resources.
  • Assess the effectiveness of prior educational campaigns.
  • Document your educational efforts in case of an audit.
Records and Errors

Maintain records and correct errors.

  • Do you retain original signed plan documents and service agreements, including any board resolutions authorizing the provisions?
  • Have you kept all policies and provisions that govern the plan (e.g., employee handbook or employer policy records)?
  • Do you keep enrollment forms and Retirement Contribution Agreements for participants?
  • Have you maintained hardship and loan documentation, especially if you have other providers or plans?
  • Use the IRS Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System (EPCRS): IRS.gov/Retirement-Plans/Correcting-Plan-Errors.
Goals and Objectives

Review plans to make sure they meet your goals.

  • Have you documented your goals and objectives for your retirement benefits program?
  • Would you allow GuideStone to walk you through your retirement plan to evaluate if changes should be considered?
  • Have you reviewed the IRS requirements for plans with multiple vendors?
  • Do you have an Information Sharing Agreement with your other providers?
  • Have you reviewed the Vendor Appendix in EAP to confirm all 403(b) providers?

Relevant Resources

If you have any questions, please contact one of our customer solutions specialists at 1-888-98-GUIDE (1-888-984-8433), Monday through Friday, 7 a.m. to 6 p.m. CT.

 

 


This checklist is not intended to be an all-encompassing list of items you must monitor as part of your fiduciary responsibility.

For more information, see the Compliance and Fiduciary Corner in the Resources section of EAP. Additional information is available at GuideStone.org/Resources/Education/Articles/Retirement/Strong-Internal-Controls-for-Audits.

GuideStone stands ready to assist your organization as you work with your legal and tax advisors if there is any information we can provide that you or your advisor may find beneficial.