Audits only happen to other people, right? Unfortunately, that is not always the case.
But there are things you can do to prepare in the event that your organization’s retirement plan is audited by the IRS, starting with implementing and maintaining strong internal controls. Taking the time to plan ahead will help you:
- Prevent potential problems and errors from arising in the first place, and
- Fulfill the basic eligibility requirement of having established compliance practices and procedures in place in the event your organization needs to use the IRS’ Self-Correction Program. Through this program, retirement plan sponsors (employers) can self-correct insignificant operational errors at any time and preserve the tax-favored status of the plan without having to pay any fees.
So, what do you do if your plan is audited? We’ll get there. First, let’s review the various types of audits that may come your way.
What are the different types of audits?
Audits generally take one of two forms:
- Full scope audits — a complete examination of the plan for form (i.e., plan language) and operational compliance which takes place at the plan sponsor’s place of business.
- Focused audits — an examination of three to five predetermined issues, based on plan and industry type.
Regardless the type of audit, good internal controls can help you find and prevent mistakes, which, left uncorrected, could endanger your plan’s tax-favored status. Therefore, it is important to implement and maintain formal review procedures and internal controls. If you do make a mistake, the IRS Employee Plans Compliance Resolution System (EPCRS) provides different methods to help correct your actions and avoid plan disqualification.1
What are internal controls?
Internal controls are business processes designed to detect and prevent mistakes in your retirement plan, and good internal controls should include the following procedures:
- Plan Operations Review
- A plan operations review allows you to verify that you operate your plan according to its written terms. As a plan sponsor, you should periodically review your plan’s operations to ensure that you are following the written terms of your plan. Regular review enables you to quickly detect and correct any mistakes.
- Three important questions to ask during a plan review are:
- Were contributions based on the correct definition of “compensation” as defined by your retirement plan document?
- Were loans and distributions made according to your plan rules?
- Were all eligible employees included in your plan in a timely manner?
- Visit the IRS “Policies, Procedures and Internal Controls Self-Audit” page for additional questions that can provide guidance as you review your plan for operational compliance.
- Plan Document Updates
- A few months before your next plan year begins, determine if there are any new laws or internal operations changes that could make it necessary to amend your plan.
- If your plan document is prepared by GuideStone®, we will automatically update it to reflect necessary legal changes.
- The most current version of your retirement plan documents provided by GuideStone is available through the GuideStone Employer Access® Program (EAP). You can find the most current version of your Plan Summary there as well.
- Internal Control Procedure Examples
- Your organization should document the step-by-step processes it takes to complete the daily tasks associated with managing your plan. The exact procedures and internal controls necessary will depend on your organization, your plan type and its features.
- Here are some examples of internal controls procedures that other plan sponsors have implemented:
- Compare completed salary deferral election forms with the amounts deducted from employees' wages.
- Verify the types of compensation used for allocations, deferrals and testing.
- Check that plan service providers received accurate information.
- Verify that years of service were accurately determined for eligibility and vesting.
- Monitor annual contribution and compensation limits*.
- Verify marital status and spousal consent for plan distributions*.
- Ensure participants received required minimum distributions*.
- *GuideStone can help with these processes.
What are common mistakes discovered during plan audits?
- Failure to timely amend the plan or to follow the terms of the plan
- It is very important that plan sponsors amend their plans for legal and operational changes in a timely manner and retain documentation of amendments in case of a plan audit. In an audit, if a plan sponsor cannot prove that the plan amendments were timely adopted, the IRS will require correction and payment of a sanction.
- To help avoid this, plan sponsors should annually review plan documents. If the error had been discovered through this yearly examination before the plan audit, the plan sponsor could have self-corrected or filed a much less expensive Voluntary Correction submission to bring the plan current with all law and operational changes.
- When plan sponsors make changes to their plan document, these changes should also be reflected in the plan’s summary plan description and communicated to plan participants. Furthermore, the plan sponsor should report changes made to the plan to all parties who provide service to the plan.
- Failure to review in-service, termination and loan distribution forms to make sure they follow the plan terms
- Many plan vendors use the same distribution forms for all of the plans they administer despite the fact that individual plans may have different distribution options and requirements. Using a generic form can lead to distribution errors and incorrect tax reporting.
- For your convenience and clarity, GuideStone provides different forms for various distribution events. Plus, GuideStone’s recordkeeping system assists in helping follow plan terms by tracking certain plan limitations on distributions.
- Failure to include all eligible employees in testing**
- Plan sponsors sometimes fail to share information with the service provider regarding:
- All employees eligible to make an elective deferral, including those terminated during the year, or
- Employees of a related company with common ownership interests.
- These employees may be eligible to participate in the plan and, therefore, may need to be included in the various nondiscrimination tests.
- **Your retirement plan may not require testing, and this information may not be relevant to your situation.
What resources and tools are available for additional assistance?
GuideStone also provides plan sponsors with annual checklists of certain internal controls a plan sponsor should review to help with plan compliance.
What do I do if our plan is chosen for an audit?
If your plan is chosen for an audit, do not hesitate to call on GuideStone so we can help you prepare and walk with you through the process. But remember, while we’re here to help, hiring a service provider such as GuideStone does not relieve you as the plan sponsor of the responsibility of keeping the plan in compliance. So, begin a plan operations and document review to evaluate the strength of your internal controls and potentially make adjustments. In the event that an audit comes, you’ll be better prepared.
1https://www.irs.gov/retirement-plans/epcrs-overview
This information should not be considered tax or legal advice. GuideStone stands ready to assist your organization as you work with your legal and tax advisers by providing resource information that you and your adviser may find beneficial.